150,000 foreign nationals staying on after visas expire

Discussion in 'News from the UK, Europe and the rest of the World' started by Kuyapablo, Jul 5, 2012.

  1. Kuyapablo
    Offline

    Kuyapablo Member

    Immigration backlog: New warning from watchdog

    Immigration minister Damian Green has pledged to improve '

    The UK Border Agency has no "clear strategy" for dealing with a group of more than 150,000 foreign nationals staying on after visas expire, the borders and immigration inspector says.

    John Vine said the group, typically foreign students, is growing in number.

    His report warned that immigration officers did not know how many of those told to leave the UK had actually left.

    Immigration minister Damian Green blamed the last government - but Labour said the report was damning.

    The latest report from the inspector focuses on a previously unknown problem in the UKBA, concerning people from outside Europe who have deadlines to leave the UK.

    Many of these people are students and if they do not leave when told to do so, they are added to the "migration refusal pool" (MRP).

    'More pro-active'
    "There are over 150,000 cases nationally of migrants who have been refused an extension of stay in the UK," said Mr Vine.

    "The Agency does not know how many of these individuals have left the country or are waiting to be removed.

    "I also saw no evidence that there is a clear plan in place for the Agency to deal with this stream of work to ensure this does not become another backlog.

    "I believe it can and must do more to demonstrate it is dealing with this issue in a more proactive manner."

    The report said the number of MRP cases had grown from 153,000 in October of last year to almost 160,000 by mid-December.

    Mr Vine said: "The Agency needs much more effective planning in place to deal with this stream of work in order to ensure it removes individuals still in the UK who have no right to be here, while setting out clear performance targets to manage these cases much more effectively."

    Immigration Minister Damian Green said "Under the last government there was no effective strategy in place to ensure migrants left at the end of their time in the UK. The UK Border Agency is now working through a group of potential over-stayers to identify those who have not left.

    "This includes checking passenger records using our e-borders database which now covers all flights outside Europe.

    "This summer the UKBA launched a UK-wide operation to remove over-stayers and we have already seen 1,800 removals since the campaign started."

    'Damning conclusion'
    But shadow home secretary Yvette Cooper said the coalition was "failing on illegal immigration."

    "The damning conclusion from the government's own immigration inspector has concluded that the government is giving a very low priority to finding and removing people who have been refused permission to stay.

    "We've had the fiasco of the border scandal, where the Home Secretary has admitted she doesn't know how many people came in without checks. We now have huge queues at our airports because of poor management and the cuts to nearly 900 UK Border Force staff."


    Source:-
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-18715036
    Last edited: Jul 5, 2012
  2. Kuyapablo
    Offline

    Kuyapablo Member

    If you were aware or suspicious that someone in the filipino community was staying in the UK after their visa had expired, what would you do? Report it? Or just think it's the UKBA's problem?
  3. Aromulus
    Offline

    Aromulus The Don Staff Member

    Though one this...........:oops:

    I suppose if the circumstances warrant I would consider some kind of action.
    But I would be very, very careful in my judgement, as normally Filipinos in general, in the UK, do not really start by wanting to cheat the system.
    They just get caught in the "magnana" trap and delay renewing visas until is too late...

    But on the main, I would suggest they go back home and re-apply..
  4. Kuyapablo
    Offline

    Kuyapablo Member

    So if someone deliberately stayed in the UK after the expiry date of their visa and had no intention of applying for an extension or new visa, what would you do? Report it? Or let it slide?

    I'm really interested in what you guys think about this scenario, both british and filipino.
  5. Micawber
    Offline

    Micawber Renowned Lifetime Member

    It's a tough question to answer.
    As for me it would depend on the circumstances and on the person

    I've had two experiences of being in that position.
    One case related to a lady who was here on a visit visa, got married (with by the way approval from the Home Office via COA) then thought she could stay on here because she was married to a Brit.
    Not going to bore everyone with all the details but I really tried hard to explain to both her and her husband everything she must do to be legal. Both refused and refused to listen. Then she received a letter saying she must leave UK and re-apply for a spouse visa.
    Whatever I told them they ignored, and even approached their MP to intervene.

    Result was she received a final warning to leave UK by October 15th voluntarily and paying her own airfare or she would be deported and banned from returning for 5 years.
    The husband lost his job, she had no money. I booked her ticket and my wife gave her some money to live on when she arrived.

    She remains in the Philippines. My wife still has a contact to her.
    The husband somehow blames me and we have had no contact since his wife left. He's a loser anyway in my book.

    At no time did I take any action to report what I knew to be incorrect.

    The other case I became involved with was rather complicated and very different.
    Again it was a lady. She had a husband in Philippines who she was supporting with medical treatment.
    When her visa expired I discovered she was actually living with her new British boyfriend and had no intention of going back home.

    I tried to advise and help her but she would not listen to me and in fact got very hostile.
    She said she needed to stay and get money to support her husband.

    I was really torn as to what I should do. Eventually I contacted her family in the Philippines and revealed everything to them and begged them to advise her. To say they were shocked was an understatement. They had received no contact and no money for at least 3 months.

    The lady moved away with her boyfriend. Her husband in Phil passed away.
    I have no idea where she is or what she's doing.

    Her family in the Philippines do not contact me anymore.

    Once you become entangled in such issues, it can become a mess.
  6. Micawber
    Offline

    Micawber Renowned Lifetime Member

    There is one other case I know about.
    It concerns a British guy who got scammed into a marriage, and scammed out of all his money. He was also treated very badly.
    Anyway, he eventually divorced this woman and promptly informed the UKBA. She had only FLR.

    I know he informed them at least a further 2 or 3 times stating she was still in UK that her FLR was expired and even giving her address and employer details.
    He also informed the employer, who promptly fired her.

    Again and again UKBA did nothing.

    Now, following some kind of investigation in the local area office it seems some action has finally been taken.
    The guy has received a message from his ex-wife that she was arrested and deported, and has returned to a miserable life in Philippines.........and it is all his fault!

    He has closure at last on a real bad part of his life. But not through the correct procedure of UKBA

    I'm pretty sure some members here will know this person's story.
  7. walesrob
    Offline

    walesrob Administrator Staff Member

    Would that be the one from Southampton/IOW area? I remember following the story over on the darkside forum.
  8. Micawber
    Offline

    Micawber Renowned Lifetime Member

  9. oss
    Offline

    oss Somewhere Staff Member

    Yes I remember his story, really nice chap but woefully blinded by love.

    Saying that anyone can make really dumb mistakes and I personally have made plenty over the last 35 years of official so called adulthood.

    Would I actively turn in anyone who was an over-stayer?

    Probably not.

    I think I might if I knew their story and there was clear deliberate malice aforethought but many many others will have a long and sad story to tell and if they find themselves in difficulty meeting the requirements here then I would not want to make things even harder by turning them in.

    Ana thought she was an overstay or "taga na taga" (TnT) in Korea in the mid 1990's, she wasn't, she was actually a citizen but she had no access to anyone with enough intelligence or authority to help her, as a result she went on the run in Korea working in the black economy fearing every waking minute that she would get caught and sent home. She actually went home because of an amnesty for TnT's in Korea and obtained a temporary travel document from the Philippine Embassy in Seoul in spite of the fact that she was no longer Filipino at the time, still no one in the Philippine embassy or elsewhere helped her or recognised the absurdity of the whole situation, so when she got home to Manila she was effectively technically taga na taga in the Philippines after 21 days as well.

    Peoples lives can get screwed up without it being their fault, most countries are over regulated with far fewer freedom's than we like to imagine we have.

    People who have travelled here from a third world country have often had to overcome a great many obstacles, they have often had to show ingenuity, resourcefulness and genuine skill, a willingness to tolerate conditions that no one here would put up with, they are not the benefit tourists, they come here and contribute one way or another.

    Now immigration from European states is perhaps another matter but that is only because there are not that many opportunities for people in the rich countries like the UK to work in Latvia or Romania and earn a decent living. We also possibly feel aggrieved because we are so awful at learning foreign languages so it's hard to work in the rich European countries, while on the other hand all those skilled European punters that come here seem to speak fluent English better than many Brits, maybe they worked hard at that :)

    On the one hand we opened the borders and said immigration is fine, free movement is fine, lets all have a big party, on the other hand we said, ah but only if you are in our club and unfortunately a lot of Brits didn't want to be in that club anyway.

    Personally I would advocate more free movement globally, the whole world is going to need that if we are to avoid wars when the see levels start to rise dramatically over the next 40 odd years.
  10. Aromulus
    Offline

    Aromulus The Don Staff Member

    I was wondering how that case was progressing.... Yeah, I bet he must be well relieved now...:like:
  11. florgeW
    Offline

    florgeW Lady Mod Senior Member

    150,000 unreported and they don't know what to do... and here we are going through the proper channel and we're the ones being penalized... crazy!
  12. oss
    Offline

    oss Somewhere Staff Member

    Yes that is the truly unforgivable bit Florge, it is so unfair on anyone who tries to do things by the book. :(
  13. Kuya
    Offline

    Kuya The Geeky One Staff Member

    Always the way.. The government loves to pick on those easiest to pick on:(
  14. Aromulus
    Offline

    Aromulus The Don Staff Member

    I would try to write an email to Theresa May directly, and ask some questions about it....;)
  15. Kuya
    Offline

    Kuya The Geeky One Staff Member

    Theresa May is above replying to people via email or what not. She has her lackies send out random auto responses..
  16. florgeW
    Offline

    florgeW Lady Mod Senior Member

    well, I sent her an email about my ILR.. the same email I sent to my local MP... didn't even get an auto reply.. b***ch!
  17. Kuya
    Offline

    Kuya The Geeky One Staff Member

    Local MP needs your vote.. Theresa May doesn't! Plus, I am pretty sure you're in a strong Labour held area, no interest to a right wing Tory like Mrs May.
  18. florgeW
    Offline

    florgeW Lady Mod Senior Member

    ahhh.. yes, i still live in an ideal world that says public service means serving the public regardless of political affiliations.. i thought such things only happen in the philippines..

Share This Page